Following the Money from Bid to Impression

How a national CPG advertiser found a path to 40% more working media

Refrigerated section in a retail supermarket

This CPG brand asked a simple question: why is our offsite retail media spend generating such poor returns?

Our hypothesis was that non-media costs were pushing the net CPM too low to compete for quality media environments. If we were right, the problem wasn’t the media plan. It was everything standing between the bid and the impression.

To test the theory, we traced 20 days of offsite spend from the advertiser’s preferred DSP to publishers’ ad server logs. One advertiser, one retail media network, one DSP. Reconciling the two data sets connected every fee between gross spend and the impression for the first time, giving the media team visibility that neither the brand nor its agency had before.

What we found

The biggest single lever was a 75-cent measurement fee for a service our client wasn’t even using. Duplicate data fees consumed another 8% of the budget.

We were surprised to find that the supply path choice was a smaller optimization opportunity lever than original anticipated.

SPO has been the media industry's default efficiency lever for a decade. Here it was the smallest one available. Two thirds of the CPM was gone before an SSP ever touched it, and moving the entire buy to the best performing path would have returned only about $6,000 relative to a $47,000 measurement fee. The spread is real, but the real money is farther upstream.

What this means for performance

The hypothesis held. A $1.72 bid landed at the publisher as just 43 cents, too little to compete for quality placements. With most of the gap upstream, this CPG advertiser had several levers it could pull, which would add an estimated 40% more working media.

The takeaways? Nearly every cost in the waterfall was disclosed but had never been connected. With this newfound visibility, each became a choice to keep, eliminate or renegotiate, and every cent recovered became bidding power in the auction. The buying team now has a path to more working media and better returns without spending a penny more.